-2%202_edited.jpg)
THE ULTIMATE COOKIE EXPERIENCE.
Your Cookie craving unlocked.
Inspired by those who came before us.
The Legacy Collection
Featured Collections
These are not your average size cookies-they're 5oz.
That's Big!
Is it a sampler? No.
Will it disappear in one setting? Probably.
Share them if you must, but, these cookies were created for indulgence.
Variety LEGACY COLLECTION
"When You Have to Have them All"
Includes 1 of each for 6-Pk
2 of each for 12-PkP:
"The Carver" -Peanut Butter
"The Tuskegee" -Chocolate Chip
"The Heritage" -Butter Pecan
"The Madame CJ"-Oatmeal Raisin
"The Fannie Lou"-Triple Chocolate
"The Harriet"-Red Velvet
TRAILBLAZER COLLECTION
"A Chocolate Lover's Dream"
Includes 2 of each for 6-Pk
4 of each for 12-Pk:
"The Tuskegee" -Chocolate Chip
"The Fannie Lou" -Triple Chocolate
"The Harriet"-Red Velvet
Meet Our Legacy Flavors
If you're a fan of Butter Pecan ice cream, these cookies are sure to win you over! They're rich, buttery, chewy, and packed with roasted pecans, all brought together with our homemade butter toffee added.
Irresistibly satisfying in every bite.
Bold. Audacious. This cookie is a cross between a brownie & a cookie. It's filled with chocolate like you've never had it before. Belgian dark chocolate, all crowned with sea salt flakes for a sweet & salty finish . It’s a dream for true chocolate lovers—and it doesn’t hold back.
These cookies are a slight twist on a delicious classic favorite. Made with organic peanut butter, these cookies are filled with a rich organic peanut butter and Belgian white chocolate filling, then sprinkled with finely chopped peanuts. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of sweet and salty peanut flavor.
This classic cookie favorite gets an elevated twist. Crafted with slowly whipped butter offering a rich, flavor perfectly balanced with just the right touch of sweetness and saltiness topped with sea salt flakes. Crisp edges lead to a soft, chewy center-filled made with premium Belgian chocolate.
It’s a gourmet nostalgic treat.
Crafted with a warm blend of hearty organic oats, plump organic sun-dried raisins, and a robust flavor of Ceylon cinnamon, These Oatmeal Raisin Cookies bring comfort with a soft, chewy center with a touch of elegance.
—another elevated classic cookie.
It's Red Velvet cake as a cookie! This delectable cookie is filled with the famous partner-cream cheese filling. Unlike traditional chocolate cookies, the chocolate flavor is mild and nuanced. We use beet root powder to give this cookie its red color. The flavor of this cookie is neither fully chocolate
nor fully vanilla.
About Our Ingredients
Our cookies are handcrafted over three days using only the freshest premium ingredients, including the world famous Belgian chocolates. We use organic flour, organic sugar, organic butter, organic eggs, and all organic aromatic spices to help keep our customers products
free of pesticides.
Both our toffee and marshmallows are handmade to give our customers the best flavors that are free of artificial additives.
testimonials
What our customers keep
saying about Nicky's Cookies
"These cookies are sooo delicious! Eating them is like eating chips- you can't eat just one"
Kristie S.
Richmond, VA
"You will not find a more delicious cookie than these! We tried ONE chocolate chip cookie and loved it so much we decided to buy a dozen each for the neighborhood. The families LOVED them immediately wanted the recipe!
Thomas C.
Newnan, GA
"The chocolate chip cookies are simply phenomenal! These cookies make you forget where you are, as you get lost in the flavor!"
Kiersten P.
ALEXANDRIA, VA
OH, MY GOODNESS! I just had the Butter Pecan and it was absolutely the best cookie I've ever tasted. PK was right; this needs to be in stores everywhere. You have a loyal customer!
Anya J.
Kentwood, MI
Our Story
Cookies & Me
Meet the Baker & Owner Nicole Royster
As a retired Army wife who proudly served alongside my husband for 20 years — and joyfully prepared countless meals and desserts for my husband and sons — I felt a pull to explore my creative side through baking in 2009. I initially began with gourmet cupcakes, but soon realized that shipping them to family & friends risked compromising their quality. Wanting to share my treats with loved ones near and far, I turned to cookies instead.
In July of 2025, I transformed my passion into a business — and my home kitchen into a licensed micro bakery. Thus, a brand was born: built on premium cookies, thoughtful design, and an experience that delights both the eyes and the palate.
From the start, I was committed to sourcing only the finest ingredients. One non-negotiable was Belgian chocolate. It was a chocolate flavor I fell in love with when we were stationed as an Army family in The Netherlands.
I knew it would elevate each bite.
Every element of Nicky's Cookies, from packaging to product, has been intentionally crafted with care. This is more than just a cookie — it’s a moment, a memory, a gift… and a heartfelt expression of who I am.